Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

The Ethical Quandary of AI-Powered Surveillance in Public Spaces

The Ethical Quandary of AI-Powered Surveillance in Public Spaces

The Growing Reality of AI-Powered Mass Surveillance

In a recent revelation by Oracle AI CTO Larry Ellison, the concept of a global network of AI-powered surveillance was proposed to ensure citizens maintain their “best behavior”. This notion, reminiscent of George Orwellโ€™s dystopian 1984, has sparked a wave of criticism highlighting the potential breach of privacy and the psychological toll such surveillance systems could impose on the public, deterring them from participating in protests and expressing free will.

However, the unsettling truth is that AI-powered mass surveillance isn’t just a future possibilityโ€”it’s already here. During this year’s Summer Olympics, the French government employed four tech companiesโ€”Videtics, Orange Business, ChapsVision, and Winticsโ€”to monitor public spaces in Paris using AI-driven video analytics to enhance security measures.

Legislation passed in 2023 enabled this initiative, allowing AI software for public data analysis and making France the first European Union country to legalise AI-powered surveillance. While this marks a new step for France, video analytics for surveillance has long been in use worldwide. The UK, for example, began installing CCTV systems in the 1960s, and as of last year, 78 of 179 OECD countries used AI for public facial recognition systems.

Privacy vs. Public Safety: The Ethical Dilemma of AI Surveillance

Privacy advocates argue that constant monitoring through video surveillance can inhibit freedom and induce anxiety among the public. On the other hand, proponents of this technology argue its necessity in the name of public safety, suggesting that such surveillance mechanisms also help keep law enforcement in check, such as requiring police officers to wear body cams.

The ethical debate questions whether tech firms should access public data and how to manage and transfer sensitive information securely among multiple stakeholders.

Decentralized Confidential Computing: A Solution to AI Data Privacy

To tackle these concerns, Decentralized Confidential Computing (DeCC) offers a promising solution. This approach removes single points of failure in data processing, a common issue in the traditional Trusted Execution Environments (TEEs) used by many AI training models.

DeCC proposes a decentralized and trustless system, where data can be analyzed without decrypting sensitive information. For instance, a video analytics tool built on a DeCC network could potentially alert security threats without exposing any personal data about the individuals recorded.

Researchers are testing techniques like Zero-knowledge Proofs (ZKPs), Fully Homomorphic Encryption (FHE), and Multi-Party Computation (MPC) for their potential to verify essential information without compromising privacy. MPC, in particular, shows promise by enabling Multi-Party eXecution Environments (MXE), where data remains encrypted and confidential during processing.

This means that even in a surveillance scenario, it is possible to maintain transparency and accountability while keeping most data confidential and secure.

While still in developmental stages, decentralized confidential computing offers a glimpse into a future where data encryption and privacy protection are paramount. As machine learning integrates into various sectors like city planning, medicine, and entertainment, the role of DeCC will be crucial in safeguarding individual privacy.

To explore more about how AI is reshaping various industries and the implications for privacy, visit our insights on Web3 and AI: The Perfect Storm and the role of AI in marketing.

As we stand at the crossroads of technological advancement and ethical governance, the path we choose must ensure the protection of fundamental human rights while embracing the benefits of innovation. The future of AI in surveillance and beyond hinges on our ability to navigate these complex ethical terrains.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Looking for your next role?
Looking to hire?